Showing posts with label IC-705. Show all posts
Showing posts with label IC-705. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 24, 2021

Is a "Poor Man's 705" possible?

While I am proud owner of multiple radios from Icom over the decades (and still own all of them) I am having a hard time cost-justifying an expensive and new shiny Icom IC-705 as part of my QRP kit, like Steve K2GOG already jumped in on. 

My Yaesu FT-817 has served me well the past twenty years which includes many ARRL Field Day's and HOPE conferences and with the 705 coming in at ~US$600 over the cost of a Yaesu FT-818ND, ~US$400 over a Elecraft KX-2, and even US$750 over a used Yaesu FT-817ND, what the premium that the IC-705 delivers is really just the same core capability as all these other fine radios, but with some fancy user interface (UI) and an improved overall user experience (UX)

The Shiny

The top three attributes often discussed about the Icom IC-705 are:

  • Color touchscreen display
  • Bluetooth and Wi-Fi connectivity
  • Compact size

To make my FT-817 or a new FT-818ND "shinier", I could buy a CAT-to-Bluetooth Adapter (US$20), use a Amazon Fire HD10 Tablet (US$15) as a touchscreen display running the 817 Companion app (Free.) This approach would allow for control of the radio, but not much else like how the Icom IC-705 integrates Wi-Fi to also offer full remote access which is very different compared to the basic bluetooth connectivity also present.

But the article is about a "Poor Mans 705." A FT-817/8 approach is still too much for your blood at ~US$700 to US$820.  We need to go much lowah ..... lowwwwaaahhhhh!

Cheap(er) Building Blocks

I recently completed building a uBitX. A QRP project with a sublime simple design blending analog and microprocessor technology. 

It is designed with experimentation in mind which can also combine a touchscreen display just like the one found on the expensive Icom radio. I figure this display upgrade would be a good start for a Poor Mans 705.

uBitx Architecture Model

The Block Model above is the uBitx with touchscreen modification. It is broken down into Analog, Digital, and Human Interface layers. 

It is important to note that the uBitx is a software-controlled radio as opposed to a software defined radio. 

In software-controlled, a microcontroller is used to control analog stages of the transceiver and interact with the user interface that makes and display changes/status. 

A software-defined radio (SDR) takes the  analog signals, converts them to the digital domain where the power of math (and coding) let us manipulate the signals to the desired analog output whether transmit or receive. The 705 is a SDR which also has software control, the best of both and you pay the price for it! 

With Arduino Nano as the microcontroller and all the uBitx code open sourced, this should help with the software learning curve.

User Interface and Experience

For those new to touchscreen projects, the Nextion HMI Display will expand your horizons when it comes to building/designing the user interface experience.  Many radio amateurs became familiar with these displays either through a uBitx project or something involving an MMDM digital hotspot. 

The Nextion has its own processor and memory that is programmed with its own editor software for developing the GUI you interact with. 

Nextion Editor with uBitx Main screen loaded

A web search will yield libraries of Amateur Radio screens made for the Nextion. The development experience is analogous (no pun intended) to front-end web development with your radio being the back-end infrastructure.  A robust community of users exists via various Facebook and Groups.io pages too.

It should be noted the Nextion does heavy processing and may introduce radio frequency interference (RFI) that may disagree with some less thoughtful HF QRP project designs. 

There are other TFTs to go with out there but few are simpler to program and addressing the RFI through the Nextion being in its own metal sub-enclosure will often suffice.

Wireless Connectivity

Anyone who has had a long history with digital modes commonly used on amateur HF spectrum is no stranger to the nest of wires and peripherals that would be built between their radio and a PC. In essence there are two services you are trying to make wireless; audio connectivity and control connectivity. 

Adding Bluetooth audio to a transceiver is a well trodden path of simple solutions  as long as you choose VOX over PTT. 

The same can be said for Bluetooth Serial device adapters that can plug into serial ports of common radio manufacturers. 

The Bluetooth serial connection is transparent to the radio control software and manufacturer protocols running across it. 

But many QRP builds do not include a serial connection nor a protocol to be used across one. The few that do like the QRPver Minion have standard on Yaesu FT-817 CAT Library.

One approach is for connectivity to be its own subsystem at the digital layer built with an ESP32. ESP32 have WiFi and Bluetooth built-in. 

Code would be built for the ESP32 to run network services (Bluetooth and WiFi) that understand various vendor protocols and give commands to the Arduino via I2C for control changes.

A Poor Mans Approach

Poor Mans Architecture

Based on what has been covered so far targeting the top three attributes of a 705, I come up with the above architecture. 

As of this publishing, I have yet to find a better source for the analog foundation than a uBitx kit which includes the microcontroller. 

For connectivity the Bluetooth Audio module and ESP32 can be readily sourced from Amazon. For the touchscreen I will go with a Nextion 4.3 inch - the same real estate as the 705.

Going larger than the available 3.5 inch touchscreen upgrade for the uBitx is going to require learning UX design with the Nextion Editor Software and the nuances of the controller running on the Nextion.

Once that is successful, adding connectivity require writing code on an ESP 32 and a routine added to the Arduino to look for I2C messages from the ESP32.

You would be correct in thinking I am planning to turn this into a fall/winter project.

 Be sure to keep an eye on the HVDN Github repo as ideation develops into design and prototype.

Any Pi?

At the Four Days in May (FDIM) 2021 annual QRP conference, the creator of the uBitx Ashhar VU2ESE announced work on the sBitx - an Open SDR using a Raspberry Pi. A PDF was published providing in-depth technical detail (that included code snippets) on their approach as well as a repo shared of code developed to date. 

Just like many of us saw with the expensive RS-BA1 remote control software that Icom sold, but has since been phased out due to competing lower cost (and better) options by the community itself, only time will tell if a combination of the sBitx and people like me will create a competitor via an open source low cost "poor man's 705".

Will be tracking this closely.

73,

- Joe, NE2Z

Wednesday, February 17, 2021

Video Games Meet Amateur Radio?

 

I always talk about "convergence" between other interests and amateur radio.  There are many hobbies that I personally find more enjoyment or motivation from by including some form of wireless communication with other things, like hiking or just finding ways to be prepared for adventures.

But what about going the opposite direction? As a long time gamer,  I made a short video to showcase the interesting form factor of the Icom IC-705 radio that may help shed an image that "ham radio" is still just about old vacuum tubes, elderly people and late nights spent in a basement tapping out Morse Code to someone around the world. Please, do not shoot your in-game missiles at me for saying that dear reader.

What is Pip Boy?

This was a fictional device featured in the very popular video game series called "Fallout". It was a wrist worn  "Personal Information Processor", manufactured by RobCo Industries.


As part of a promotional effort, many video games spawn many different real life products to engage with fans. The Pip Boy 2000 Mk VI is one example and there are even other versions that let you put a smartphone inside to offer real functionality, but in an interesting wrist mounted enclosure.   

This product even came in a special storage case when not using PipBoy. This storage case is what inspired this article and video actually.

Is is possible to put the 2 pound (1.1 kilogram) Icom IC-705 on my wrist like a PipBoy?  I guess if I got tired of my Samsung Gear watch, that could be handy to have HF and above communications while walking around. My wrist would get awfully sore though. I can keep my Icom IC-705 safe inside of a really cool case though as you will see.

A better option for wrist based communications might be KK4VCZ Travis Goodspeed's "GoodWatch" project, which I have some PCB's ready to populate with SMD components I have yet to order. 

It was easy to make the PCB's by sending the files to OSHpark and let them make the circuit boards for a few dollars. Eventually I will get around to making my own GoodWatch....

For those that may remember, Travis is the guy behind what we owe a lot to for making DMR a popular digital voice mode in amateur radio thanks to his "hacks" on the popular TYT MD-380 radio that improved its functionality greatly in such a cheap radio.  

And, the also super famous AC2SN Limor Fried who founded Adafruit has also spent time making use of Travis's interesting work made DMR super popular too. 

You could even receive signals from your Pi-Star Hotspot using the GoodWatch since Pi-Star also supports POCSAG, an open paging standard which DAPNET brought to amateur radio.

Could the Icom IC-705 with its Wi-Fi,  Bluetooth, GPS, color touch display and all mode 1.8 to 450 MHz 10 W transceiver be the next big thing that "hackers" start to experiment with?   Could it even find its way into a cosplay scenario at the next big Comicon? Maybe even getting some of the #DEFCON crowd interested too! 

And now without further ado, I present my video that most video game fans may appreciate......


Thursday, October 10, 2019

October 2019 Global Digital Repeater Round Up



Twice a year, HVDN tracks the total growth of digital voice repeaters.  Since 2016, there has been a tremendous increase of repeaters that support DMR, P25, NXDN, Fusion and D-Star digital voice amateur communication.  All but one of these modes are showing fantastic growth. Lets find out which...


October 2019 Global Digital Voice Repeater Roundup


According to repeaterbook.com data, DMR is the first digital voice mode to surpass the 3,000 repeater mark globally.

Just as long as those updating this website do so with accurate details, if you were traveling somewhere today and could only take one radio with you, a DMR radio along with its legacy analog FM capability would be the best choice followed by Yaesu Fusion and Icom D-Star. 

The chances are also higher that an area with more of one type of digital voice repeater may also have more simplex activity or non-internet connected digital voice repeaters, so it could not hurt to program appropriate digital voice channels or scan around for even more repeaters than what repeaterbook.com may list.

The P25 and NXDN commercial mode amateur radio repeaters are too limited on a global scale, but may have pockets of high activity in certain geographies. Any example of this from a NXDN perspective was covered in an HVDN article entitled "NXDN: What is it and where is it?" which may be be updated in the coming year.

Considering that both of these modes do not have any amateur market only equipment available, its still interesting to see higher percentage growth over the same time period compared to Icom D-Star, which is the oldest digital amateur voice mode currently available as detailed in a presentation on Digital Modes and Hot Spots given by Joe, N1JTA at the Trenton Computer Festival.






In a three year span from October 2016 to October 2019, here are the growth percentages of digital voice repeaters:

  • Yaesu Fusion = 80.43%
  • Icom D-Star =  17.64%
  • DMR = 101.94%
  • P25 = 108.45%
  • NXDN = 52.43%

Even though DMR is the most popular, Yaesu Fusion is close behind.  The best "audio" according to many is found on Fusion and also translates the best to other modes via Pi-Star, including P25.

It would also be wise to travel with one of the MMDVM Pi-Star "hot spot" devices which can fill in gaps where there is no repeater coverage, but where there is internet access.

The DMR and Fusion modes also offer the most flexibility for mode translation, which means that you can use a DMR or Fusion radio with a hot spot to "talk through" other mode networks such as all those listed here with little exception. Further detail on this can be found on the Pi-Star website.  Thanks to these two modes, we may see a growth of P25 and NXDN as a result. 




What drives digital voice repeater growth?


To access a repeater, you need a hand held or mobile digital voice radio.  Since a repeater is expensive, those who decide to install one often know that there are users with radios that may access the repeater.

Another driving reason for digital voice repeater growth is a wide array of equipment and cost points.  DMR has seen success because of lower cost "entry level" radios selling for as little as $60 USD such as the Baofeng DM-1801 or Radioddity GD-77, but also higher end equipment thanks to better quality radios marketed to both the amateur and commercial user too numerous to list here. 

Many vendors are also selling DMR equipment which creates more choice for buyers and this competition is a good thing should someone have had a personal bad experience with one vendor for one reason or another. 

Yaesu Fusion is the only mode that has only one vendor behind it, but offers equipment at various prices and incentives to entice buyers. This strategy has certainly helped Yaesu since prior to 2018, it followed the same "hold the price high" strategy that Icom has adopted.

Both Yaesu Fusion and DMR also offer different accessory options such as microphones, chargers and batteries to ensure a buyer stays within a particular brand of equipment. Yaesu generally has great fan's of its equipment and this was a smart move to ensure brand loyalty. A recent example of this was the same battery pack can be used with the FT-2DR and its latest FT-3DR model.

Icom is the majority equipment vendor for D-Star with only Kenwood having a single radio capable of this GFSK based digital voice mode.  The cost to license the underlying technology from the JARL is very high and has prevented other vendors from embracing this technology.

Impact 2020: The latest digital voice radios

There are two very exciting new digital voice radios just about to come to market directed at the amateur radio community. Both offer features not just for digital voice mode users, so these create two great ways for people to expand interest in different parts of the hobby.

The Icom IC-705 is the first highly portable D-Star radio that combines 2m and 70cm capability along with HF for long range communication.  This new radio also allows the Icom ID-51 handheld radio battery to be used with the IC-705, so for those that have this other radio and its accessories on hand, buying this radio for portable use could be a good long term decision.




The main market Icom is looking to gain market share in with this radio clearly is the market category that the Yaesu FT-817 expanded back in 2001 .  Both radios and the 2018 refresh version of the original FT-817 named the FT-818 have competition from Xiegu, Elecraft and a few others that sell portable QRP power HF equipment. Icom could make the IC-705 a real winner, but for every reason not related to D-Star.





There are many other reasons that make the IC-705 interesting, but are outside the scope of this article.  However, it was worth mentioning that Icom does appear to be trying to maintain ecosystem users since the Icom ID-51 has proven popular and could be a good way to sell many IC-705.

Looking at the DMR ecosystem, the long awaited Anytone AT-D578UVIII is going to offer a 2m/70cm model for outside of North America and a version with the 220 MHz 1.25m band in the United States and Canada.  Expected availability for purchase is now late October due to manufacturing issues given the current economical climate or other factors.

This mobile radio will also be the first DMR radio to offer true dual band. dual receive capability. While this radio lacks a remote head for more flexible installations in a vehicle, this radio will certainly become popular for many reasons, including use from a home location.

With the only other mobile DMR radios being somewhat limited, if Anytone has learned from past education, this radio is going to become very popular, very quickly.  Since a mobile radio offers extended range while mobile, this single radio may influence even more DMR repeaters to come online in 2020.



Digital Voice Repeater Outlook

Based on a global estimate of 19,500 analog repeaters, in time this number will shrink as equipment becomes not worth repairing or being able to be re-purposed for digital modes.  Digital repeaters may reach the total number of global analog repeaters one day, but will never truly replace nearly 40 years of analog advancements.  The official estimate of HVDN is that by the end of 2021, there should be over 11,000 digital voice amateur repeaters globally. 

Past Global Digital Repeater Round Up Articles